Born out of a devastating real estate depression, built in the shadow of a stock
market bubble, and tempered by their first recession, today’s real estate investment trusts (REITs) have re-invented the real estate industry over the past dozen or so years during what is known as the modern REIT era. Notably, REITs have outperformed over both the short and long terms amidst a variety of market fundamentals.
Portfolio spoke with 18 professionals who have built a reputation in the REIT industry. To get a broad range of perspectives we interviewed individuals on the debt side, equity investors, investment bankers and REIT CEOs across a range of sectors.
We asked each to answer a single question based on their area of expertise: Given the strides the industry has made, what is the state of the REIT marketplace looking forward? Here’s what they had to say.
Managing the REIT Market
Garrett Thornburg
Chairman and CEO
Thornburg Mortgage, Inc., Santa Fe, N.M.
For the second consecutive year, Thornburg Mortgage was named one of the top 50 best performing stocks out of 1,000 companies by The Wall Street Journal.
"In 2004, mortgage REITs raised more equity capital from initial public offerings, follow-on offerings, and conversions to mortgage REITs than the entire equity REIT market. This growing interest in mortgage REITs goes beyond
historically low mortgage interest rates.
Today, investors are learning that mortgage REITs offer many different investment strategies. Some make money by originating and selling mortgages.
Others invest in existing mortgages or mortgage backed securities (MBS). At Thornburg Mortgage, we follow still a different strategy. Our profitability is based on the spread between the interest income derived from the adjustable
rate mortgage assets we originate
and acquire and the interest expense
of our borrowings."
Steven Roth
Chairman and CEO
Vornado Realty Trust, New York, N.Y.
Vornado is one of the largest REITs in the nation, owning and/or managing over 87 million square feet of office, retail and showroom properties, with a total market capitalization of $8.64 billion. Roth was honored with NAREIT's 2004 Industry Leadership Award and served as NAREIT chair during 2003. In 2005, Barron's recognized him as one of its 30 Most Respected CEOs worldwide.
"Our industry matured in the '90s and boomed in the millennium. REIT returns exceeded all indices. The period saw deleveraging, abundant capital, professional management, product specialization, and consolidation, especially in the
regional mall segment, with its three
giants, which may be a precursor.
Five years out, I see more founders turning the reins over to professional managers, more consolidation forming more giant companies, more development by the public companies, cross globalization with U.S. companies buying abroad and vice versa, branding by the giant companies, and an emphasis on delivering quality product and service to our tenants. Rapid growth, buying assets and companies, will continue. Rising rents will more than offset slightly more hostile capital markets. The surprise may well be interest by financial services players in real estate companies."
Debra A. Cafaro
Chair, President and CEO
Ventas, Inc., Louisville, Ky.
Ventas owns 31 senior housing facilities, 41 hospitals, 201 skilled-nursing facilities and 19 other health care and senior housing
facilities containing approximately 33,300 licensed beds and senior living units located in 39 states throughout the country. Cafaro ranked 10th on The Wall Street Journal's recent "50 Women to Watch" list.
"After 10 years of exceptional performance, REITs are moving into adolescence. By that I mean we'll likely see more explosive growth combined with more volatility, given the rise of exchange traded funds that enable investors to move rapidly in and out of REIT stocks. Investor demographics may mitigate this volatility. As retiring baby boomers
demand more relatively safe, high-yielding securities, capital inflows to REITs should increase.
On the management side, the retail, hotel and health care REITs have begun to extract undervalued real estate from operating
companies and unlock value for investors. If property values and financing markets remain strong, this trend could accelerate."
Scott Rechler
Chairman, CEO and President
Reckson Associates Realty Corp., Melville, N.Y.
Reckson is one of the largest publicly traded owners, managers
and developers of Class A office properties in the New York Tri-State area, with 89 properties comprised of approximately 16.3 million square feet either owned, controlled, or under contract. In April
2004, Reckson received the "Developer of the Year" award from
the Association for a Better Long Island and the Commercial
Industrial Brokers Society of Long Island.
"Maturing REIT markets have dramatic implications for REITs and the general real estate markets. The liquidity of REIT markets have enabled public real estate companies to quickly access more cost effective capital and become more competitive players in the real estate
markets. Growing REIT and securitized debt markets have produced a more
efficient real estate market. Today, simply having access to
information and capital are no longer the only keys to successful real estate transactions. Real estate companies and entrepreneurs are being forced to be more creative and more efficient at
executing their plans. The by-product of this is a more effective
and efficient real estate industry."
John Bucksbaum
CEO
General Growth Properties, Inc., Chicago, Ill.
General Growth completed the largest REIT merger in 2004 when
it acquired The Rouse Company, and its 40 million square feet of
retail space, for a reported $7 billion. General Growth is the second-largest shopping center owner, developer and manager of regional shopping malls in the U.S. The company also received an "A+" for performance in Forbes' 2004 REIT rankings.
"Over the past decade, individual REITs have distinguished themselves as companies and should not be viewed strictly as a collection of assets. I hope that investors will begin to recognize the distinction. In the past, investors have
relied on net asset values (NAVs) to
value REIT stocks. While this is a good
measurement, it is only one. Today, many REITs have earned the right to be judged by cash flow growth, earnings per share growth, dividend growth, and other financial metrics that reflect the value added to NAV by strong management and good processes. In the end, it is people and what they do that make real estate assets profitable."
REIT Equity Market
T. Ritson Ferguson
CIO, Managing Director
ING Clarion Real Estate Securities, Radnor, Pa.
The ING Clarion Global Real Estate Income Fund, the largest closed-end real estate fund in the U.S., raised $1.35 billion in
its initial public offering in 2004.
"The next great REIT story will be globalization. Since J-REITs were introduced in Japan in 2000, 15 companies have gone public. Today, their combined market capitalization is
$17 billion. REIT structures have recently sprung up in France, Hong Kong and Taiwan. Germany and the United Kingdom
will soon follow. Globalization already offers U.S. REITs
opportunities for international investment and capital acquisition, and the trend can only grow stronger.
At the same time, real estate will remain a local industry.
In coming years, the strongest real estate companies will
combine local market expertise with global capital, bringing many opportunities to investors with global views."
Reg Pfeifer, CFA
REIT Portfolio Manager
Thrivent Financial for Lutherans, Appleton, Wis.
In 2004, Thrivent sold $114 million of direct real estate holdings and invested those assets into REITs. In its general insurance
account portfolio of about $35 billion, there is $175 million allocated to REITs. A real estate securities option in its flexible premium
deferred variable annuity product started with $5 million in initial seed money and now has assets of more than $115 million.
"Equity REITs have provided investors with exceptional
returns over the last decade14 percent annually. Over the
next five years, returns will likely revert to their long-term
average of approximately 12 percent. Improving fundamentals will provide meaningful net operating income growth over
the balance of this decade.
REITs enable investors to diversify their real estate
portfolios geographically and by property type. They provide an attractive combination of income, growth and portfolio
diversification. These factors will continue to drive increasing allocations to real estate in individual and institutional portfolios. Public equity REITs will be the primary beneficiaries because of their liquidity, strong management teams and high quality portfolios."
Samuel Lieber
President
Alpine Mutual Funds, Purchase, N.Y.
The Alpine U.S. Real Estate Equity Fund ranks
as the top-performing REIT mutual fund over
the past five years (with an annual total return
of 32 percent), according to Lipper.
"Looking back on 19 years of investing in REITs, I believe that operating performance and investor sentiment have had the greatest impact on share prices and the sector's expansion. Increasingly, both investors' needs and REIT management's goals are linked in terms of total return expectations, which have attracted a growing investor base. While scale alone can't sustain performance, it can enable operational flexibility across property types and continents leveraging growth through fund management and alternative investments. Soon, a realignment of REIT valuations will favor progressive growth companies over spread
investors. Investors will continue to follow performance."
Theodore Bigman
Managing Director, Global Investor Group
Morgan Stanley, New York, N.Y.
The Morgan Stanley Institutional European Real Estate Fund was the top-performing REIT mutual fund in 2004 with a total return of 47.5 percent, according to Lipper rankings. The
Bigman-led Morgan Stanley Institutional U.S. Real Estate Fund also ranked in the top 10 in 2004 with a 37.3 percent total return.
"In coming years, the REIT market will likely continue growing dramatically. Forces driving REIT growth include greater acceptance by institutional investors; the conviction that REIT performance correlates strongly with real estate and only modestly with equities and bonds; and superior REIT management teams. Most compelling, REITs today own only 15 percent of institutional
quality assets and should increase their market share over time.
While REITs have significantly outperformed other asset classes for the past five years, investors must remember that REITs should generally provide returns that are greater than bonds but lower than equities over the long term. Investors that use REITs appropriately will find a bright future in real estate securities."
REIT Capital Markets
Doug Rubenstein
Managing Director and Real Estate Group Coordinator
A.G. Edwards, St. Louis, Mo.
A.G. Edwards has consistently been among the top five
underwriters of real estate securities over the past five years.
Rubenstein is in his 20th year in the industry.
"Following years of strong REIT equity growth, market setbacks in early 2005 may have discouraged some investors. Then again, a few months cannot necessarily
characterize higher quality REIT equities and argue against continued good performance. Even as the market declined at the beginning of the year, most property sectors offered retail and institutional investors a choice of excellent REITs with strong, established management, low-cost debt, solid finances, efficient, cost-controlled operations, reliable cash flow for dividends, and opportunities for growth.
While strategies may change from broad investment across the industry to more selective buying, investors will continue to
find REIT opportunities in coming years."
Lawrence Gray
Managing Director and Head of Real Estate Corporate Finance
Wachovia Securities, Richmond, Va.
Wachovia Securities ranks among the top five investment banks in providing merger and acquisition advisory services and leading bank lines and underwriting of public debt and equity securities for REITs, according to Thomson Financial.
"In recent years, investors have watched equity REITs withstand a recession without compromising their balance sheets or cutting their dividends. Several REITs have been added to equity market indices, and REIT stocks have significantly outperformed most every sector of the equity market.
In short, REITs have finally earned the credibility they deserve within the broad investment markets. This credibility is compounding with demand for yield-
oriented stocks from an aging investor base, and manifesting itself in the steady funds flows to various investment vehicles focused on real estate stocks.
Longer term, I expect to see increased liquidity, expanded breadth of acceptance of REITs as an asset class and, ultimately, continued growth of this segment of the
equity market."
Jackson Hsieh
Managing Director and Global Head of
Real Estate, Lodging & Leisure Group
UBS Investment Bank, New York, N.Y.
UBS Investment Bank ranked first in most book-run global REIT common stock offerings (36 issues) and second for U.S. book-run REIT common stock offerings (15 issues) in 2004,
according to Thomson Financial data.
Hsieh moderated the 2005 Portfolio Investor Outlook roundtable.
"Investors seeking diversification and allocation alternatives will increasingly turn to REITs in coming years for two reasons. Thanks to the investment performance of REITs during the past 10 years, coupled with the transparency of management/operations and investor liquidity, investors now consider this asset class among mainstream investment alternatives. Increasing institutional allocations to REITs as well as the continuing adoption of new REIT structures by countries around the world support this contention.
Second, research completed by Ibbotson Associates has
underscored the contribution REITs can make to diversify
and enhance investment returns due to REITs low correlation to large stocks, small stocks and long-term bonds. Ibbotson tested model investment portfolios that had REIT allocations of 10 percent to 20 percent, which performed better than investment portfolios that excluded REITs."
Christopher Niehaus
Managing Director
Morgan Stanley, New York, N.Y.
Morgan Stanley was the lead bank on more than $1 billion in global REIT common stock
offerings in 2004 and more than $900 million
in U.S. preferred stock offerings, according
to Thomson Financial. Niehaus is a program
director at NAREIT's 2005 Institutional
Investor Forum.
"Since 1990, REITs have grown from $6 billion to $300 billion in market capitalization. This phenomenal growth has put the U.S. in the vanguard of a new era of global real estate securitization.
The hard part is over, but challenges remain. U.S. REITs must now develop strategies to continue growing. REIT management will have to think more broadly. For example, REITs may have to expand their geographic footprints. Regional companies may have to go national. National companies may have to go international. REITs may also have to expand their product footprints, moving into related, but different property sectors."
REIT Debt Market
Michael J. Brody
Partner, Tax Department
Latham & Watkins, LLP, Los Angeles, Calif.
Latham & Watkins LLP was the leading
law firm in terms of both REIT debt and equity
issuance in 2003, according to data provided
by Thomson Financial in the most recent
"American Lawyer Corporate Scorecard."
"Low interest rates helped drive the strong performance of REITs in recent
years. Low rates allowed even low-leveraged REITs to earn
significant spreads on the difference between rental rates and
interest rates. Moreover, low rates have boosted property
values and returns from portfolio management techniques
such as asset sales.
Looking ahead, an improving economy will likely result
in rising interest rates. But economic growth will also reduce
vacancies and boost rental rates for REITs. It's entirely possible that revenue increases will equal or exceed the cost of higher
interest rates, and allow REITs to maintain strong earnings. Consequently, REITs appear to be positioned to continue to
perform well in the coming years."
Tara Innes
Managing Director
Fitch Ratings, New York, N.Y.
Fitch Ratings is a leading global rating
agency that evaluates credit markets.
Innes is the team leader responsible for
ratings and analysis on REITs and real
estate operating companies.
"The REIT sector has matured over the last decade, growing in terms of size and acumen. REIT management teams have demonstrated sound judgment through challenging property markets by improving asset quality, conservatively managing leverage, and diversifying funding sources. The sector has also benefited from a
significant broadening of investor interest in real estate and REIT securities.
Offsetting progress in financial management and investor
interest, REIT operating models have become increasingly
complex with the proliferation of joint ventures and merchant building activities. In addition, debt protection measures
have been weakened by financial covenant changes. I expect
REITs to continue to evolve through the expansion of their
operating platforms."
Lisa Sarajian
Managing Director, Real Estate Finance Group
Standard & Poor's, New York, N.Y.
Sarajian oversees a team of seven analysts, which as a group
assess the credit quality of 100 domestic operating real estate
companies, including developers, homebuilders, private trusts
and REITs, which have roughly $100 billion in rated securities outstanding.
"REITs successfully managed the challenges of their first decade in the public spotlight. The growing economy and
expanded access to capital early in the cycle provided the portfolio diversity and
balance sheet strength required to withstand the later downturn, though weaker companies liquidated or merged with stronger players. But the investment
landscape for institutional-quality properties is dramatically more competitive today, and lower yields are forcing many REITs to invest more creatively. As a result, we see REITs
beginning to shift gears a bit, which could mean greater
rewards for some, but greater risks for others."
John J. Kriz
Managing Director of Real Estate Finance, Fixed Income Analyst
Moody's Investors Service, New York, N.Y.
Kriz has 20 years of global securities research experience
in a broad range of real estate firms and financial institutions.
Moody's is a leading provider of independent credit ratings,
research and financial information.
"The REIT market is strong and getting stronger, here in
the U.S. and around the world. In the U.S., REITs have firmly
established themselves as an investment-grade fixture in the debt markets.
But REITs are not just making it here. They're making it everywhere. For example, in recent years REIT structures have been adopted in Japan, Singapore and Hong Kong, and they
are well established in Canada, Holland and Australia. Several European countries have announced plans to create REITs. Greater global acceptance is a new wind in the sails of the U.S. REIT market.
The next stage for U.S. REITs will involve growing
global investments and increasing activity via joint ventures
and investment fund structures."
William Stafford
Co-Portfolio Manager
Westcore Plus Bond Fund, Denver, Colo.
Denver Investment Advisors' bond
portfolio, which includes the Westcore
Plus Bond Fund, totals approximately
$300 million in REIT assets.
"Over the past few years, REITs have demonstrated that they can outperform in a down real estate market, while offering
debt investors significant protection. Even today REIT bonds typically yield 100 basis points more than 10-year
Treasuries, higher than A-rated industrial companies or financial institutions. And we're always happy to clip the
excess yield.
Looking ahead, we remain positive about REIT debt. We also believe that REIT equities remain fundamentally
undervalued on a cash flow basis. Recent acquirers consistently paid significant premiums to net asset value. When
equities are undervalued, they don't
reflect the real economic value of the
underlying assets, further benefiting bondholders."